FairCheck HR in your Pocket

Home / Articles

Above award, still underpaid: the blind spot in early learning payroll

“We pay above award.”

It is the sentence we hear most often at the start of a payroll review, and it is almost always said with complete confidence. It is also the sentence that most often precedes the underpayment we end up finding.

The problem is rarely dishonesty. It is that “above award” is a comparison, and most organisations are comparing against the wrong number.

What people are actually comparing

When a business manager says a salary sits above the award, they almost always mean it sits above the base rate for that classification. That is a real figure, it is easy to find, and it is only the starting point of what an award requires.

The award cost of an employee is not the base rate. It is the base rate plus whatever the award adds for the hours that person actually works. Early morning and evening loadings. Weekend penalties. Overtime beyond the span of ordinary hours. Allowances that attach to the role. Superannuation on all of it.

A salary can sit comfortably above the base rate and still fall short once those are counted.

How it plays out

Consider an early learning centre operating extended hours to suit working parents, opening before 7am and closing after 6pm.

An educator is engaged on an annual salary several thousand dollars above the classification minimum. Everyone involved is satisfied that it is generous, and measured the way they are measuring it, they are right.

The roster puts that educator on an opening shift starting at 6:45am and a closing shift finishing at 6:15pm. Under the applicable award, those hours sit outside the ordinary span and attract a loading. Nobody applies it, because nobody is looking past the base rate.

Three years later the position is reconciled properly. The shortfall is small on any single shift and significant in total, and superannuation is owed on top of it.

Nothing in that sequence requires anybody to have behaved badly. It only requires the comparison to have been made once, at the start, against the base rate, and never again.

Why centres attached to schools are more exposed

Two reasons, and both are structural rather than anybody’s fault.

The first is award coverage. Staff in an early learning centre are often not covered by the same award as the rest of a school’s staff, and early childhood teachers may sit under a different instrument again. A centre administered alongside the school, through the same payroll process and the same set of assumptions, can quietly inherit the wrong rules.

The second is hours. School support roles tend to sit inside a predictable span. Early learning does not. Extended opening, split shifts, vacation programs and staggered rosters produce exactly the pattern of hours that awards price differently, and exactly the pattern that a salary set once at the start does not track.

The contract point most people miss

There is a widely held assumption that an annual salary automatically absorbs award entitlements. It does not do so by default.

For a salary to offset award entitlements, the contract generally needs to say so, and to identify what the salary is intended to cover. Even where it does, it does not automatically follow that an overpayment in one period can be used to make good a shortfall in another. The reconciliation still has to happen.

A generous salary sitting behind a silent contract is not protection. It is an unquantified exposure.

Four things worth checking

  1. Confirm the award for each role in the centre, separately from the school. Do not assume one answer covers everyone on the site.
  2. Take the hours as they are actually worked, not as the roster was designed. Start and finish times are where the money is.
  3. Read the employment contracts for a set-off clause, and check that it names what it is meant to absorb.
  4. Reconcile at least annually, against what the award produces for the hours worked, rather than against the base rate.

Why it matters more now

Underpayment is no longer only a back-pay conversation. Intentional underpayment became a criminal offence in 2025. Honest mistakes are not the target of those provisions, but the direction of travel is unmistakable, and regulators and the public are increasingly treating payroll accuracy as a governance question rather than an administrative one.

For a school, the reputational exposure usually arrives well before any legal one does. These matters are rarely private for long.

The reassuring part is that this is a solvable problem. It is arithmetic against a published instrument. It only becomes expensive when nobody does the arithmetic for three years.

Do the arithmetic against the award, not the base rate

FairCheck checks a payslip against the award that applies to the role, for the hours actually worked, including loadings, penalties, overtime, allowances and super, and shows the clause behind every figure. The free check needs no account.

FairCheck provides general information about Australian pay rules and does not provide legal advice. Whether a salary offsets award entitlements depends on the award, the contract and the hours worked. Official information is available from the Fair Work Ombudsman at fairwork.gov.au.