It depends entirely on whether the underpayment was intentional. For the criminal offence, an individual faces up to 10 years imprisonment, a fine, or both, and a company faces a fine calculated as the higher of three times the underpayment or a fixed maximum.
For an honest mistake, which is not criminal, the consequences are civil: repaying the employee with interest, and potentially a compliance notice, an enforceable undertaking or civil penalties. In every case the money owed has to be repaid, and that obligation is separate from any penalty.
Figures checked on 18 November 2026 against guidance published by the Fair Work Ombudsman and the Commonwealth penalty unit of $364, which applies to conduct on or after 1 July 2026. The unit value in force when the conduct happened is the one that applies, so earlier conduct is calculated at a lower rate. General information, not legal advice.
Criminal penalties
These apply only to the intentional underpayment offence in force since 1 January 2025. They do not apply to honest mistakes.
| If the underpayment can be calculated | If it cannot be calculated | Prison | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Company | The higher of 3× the underpayment or $9.1 million | $9.1 million | Not applicable |
| Individual | The higher of 3× the underpayment or $1.82 million | $1.82 million | Up to 10 years |
Note the structure. The fine is not capped at the fixed figure, it is the higher of the two, so it scales with the size of the underpayment. A court may impose a fine, prison time, or both.
Civil consequences, which are the ones most employers will meet
An honest mistake is not a crime, but it is not consequence free. The Fair Work Ombudsman has a ladder of civil enforcement options, and these remain available even where a safe harbour blocks a criminal referral.
| Action | What it is | When it tends to be used |
|---|---|---|
| Back-pay and interest | Repaying what was owed | Always. This is not a penalty, it is the debt |
| Compliance notice | A formal direction to fix a contravention | Where a contravention is identified and can be rectified |
| Enforceable undertaking | A binding written commitment to rectify and improve | Where an employer cooperates and commits to change |
| Civil litigation | Court proceedings seeking civil penalties | More serious or systemic contraventions |
Civil penalty amounts under the Fair Work Act are higher for serious contraventions and for larger employers, and the maximum amounts changed from 1 July 2026. Because the Fair Work Ombudsman has flagged that its published materials are under review, we are not publishing civil penalty figures here rather than risk quoting stale numbers. Check the current amounts directly with the Ombudsman.
The number that actually determines the cost
In practice, the size of an underpayment liability is rarely driven by the amount in any one pay period. It is driven by two multipliers: how long the error ran, and how many people it touched.
A configuration error worth twenty dollars a fortnight, affecting fourteen people, running for four years, is a little over twenty-nine thousand dollars in wages before interest. Nobody noticed it, because on any single payslip it was twenty dollars.
| Factor | Detail |
|---|---|
| Recovery window | Generally six years from when the entitlement fell due |
| Record keeping | Employee records must be kept for seven years |
| Missing records | A reverse onus can apply, so the employer may have to disprove the alleged underpayment |
That last row is the one worth sitting with. If you cannot produce adequate records, you can end up arguing against a claimed figure without the evidence to rebut it.
What reduces exposure
- Finding it yourself. How an underpayment came to light is a factor the Ombudsman considers. A payroll error identified in your own audit reads very differently to one identified by an employee complaint.
- Fixing it promptly, and taking steps to stop it recurring.
- Cooperating with any inquiry or investigation.
- Being able to show reasonable steps were taken to get pay right in the first place: which award you checked, how you classified people, when you last reviewed rates.
- For fewer than 15 employees, satisfying the Voluntary Small Business Wage Compliance Code, which blocks a criminal referral entirely.